| Year |
Team |
Individual |
| 1952 |
North Texas State |
Marion Hiskey, North Texas State |
| 1953 |
Hardin–Simmons University |
Tommy Hale, Hardin–Simmons University |
| 1954 |
North Texas State |
Marion Hiskey, North Texas State |
| 1955 |
North Texas State |
Ray Ferguson, North Texas State |
| 1956 |
Lamar Tech |
Bunky Johnson, Lamar Tech |
| 1957 |
Lamar Tech |
Jim Curti, Rollins College |
| 1958 |
Lamar Tech |
Eddie Langer, Lamar Tech |
| 1959 |
Western Illinois University |
Jim King, Western Illinois University |
| 1960 |
Lamar Tech |
Bill Wright, Western Washington State College |
| 1961 |
Lamar Tech |
Bill Levely, Lamar Tech |
| 1962 |
Western Illinois University |
Steve Spray, Eastern New Mexico University |
| 1963 |
Eastern New Mexico University |
Steve Spray, Eastern New Mexico University |
| 1964 |
Texas Wesleyan College |
Craig Mertz, East Texas State |
| 1965 |
East Texas State |
Craig Mertz, East Texas State |
| 1966 |
University of Southwestern Louisiana |
Don Iverson, Wisconsin State University–La Crosse |
| 1967 |
University of Southwestern Louisiana |
John Bohmann, Texas Lutheran College |
| 1968 |
Indiana University of Pennsylvania |
Rick Hrip, Indiana University of Pennsylvania |
| 1969 |
Texas Wesleyan College |
Ken Hyland, Malone College |
| 1970 |
Campbell University |
Jimmy Chapman, Southwest Texas State University |
| 1971 |
Saint Bernard College |
Sammy Rachels, Columbus College |
| 1972 |
U.S. International University |
Gaylord Burrows, Eastern Illinois University
Jim McAnally, Angelo State University |
| 1973 |
Wofford College |
Jay Overton, Campbell University
Mike Zack, Saint Bernard College |
| 1974 |
U.S. International University |
Dan Frickey, Washburn University |
| 1975 |
Texas Wesleyan College |
Dan Gray, Texas Wesleyan College |
| 1976 |
Gardner–Webb University |
Will Brewer, David Lipscomb College |
| 1977 |
Gardner–Webb University |
Jim Bromley, Campbell University |
| 1978 |
Sam Houston State University |
Greg Brown, Point Loma College |
| 1979 |
Sam Houston State University |
Robert Thompson, Sam Houston State University |
| 1980 |
Sam Houston State University |
Tom Allbright, Sam Houston State University
Danny Mijovic, Texas Wesleyan College |
| 1981 |
Sam Houston State University |
Danny Mijovic, Texas Wesleyan College |
| 1982 |
Elon University |
Danny Mijovic, Texas Wesleyan College |
| 1983 |
Cameron University |
Dow Brian, Texas Wesleyan College
Bill Brooks, Guilford College
Danny Mijovic, Texas Wesleyan College |
| 1984 |
Limestone College |
Chip Johnson, Limestone College |
| 1985 |
Huntingdon College |
Dan Penny, Huntingdon College |
| 1986 |
Huntingdon College |
Jon Hough, Kennesaw College
Rob Odom, Guilford College |
| 1987 |
Huntingdon College |
Joe Durant, Huntingdon College |
| 1988 |
Huntingdon College |
David Schreyer, Huntingdon College |
| 1989 |
Guilford College |
Nicky Martin, Huntingdon College |
| 1990 |
Texas Wesleyan University |
Andy Fuller, Texas Wesleyan University |
| 1991 |
University of North Florida |
Cam Beckman, Texas Lutheran College |
| 1992 |
Huntingdon College |
Jamie Burns, University of North Florida
Scott Gardner, Cumberland College |
| 1993 |
University of North Florida |
Jamie Burns, University of North Florida |
| 1994 |
Huntingdon College |
Henrik Nyström, Lynn University |
| 1995 |
Texas Wesleyan University |
Steve Armstrong, Pfeiffer College |
| 1996 |
Lynn University |
Steve Galko, Texas Wesleyan University |
| 1997 |
University of Mobile |
Keith Hoard, Spring Hill College |
| 1998 |
Berry College |
Chris Gaines, Texas Wesleyan University |
| 1999 |
Texas Wesleyan University |
Brent Osachoff, Simon Fraser University |
| 2000 |
Malone College |
David Tuyo, University of Mobile |
| 2001 |
Oklahoma City University |
Justin Walters, Huntingdon College |
| 2002 |
Oklahoma City University |
Tyrone Van Aswegen, Oklahoma City University |
| 2003 |
Oklahoma City University |
Nicolas Allain, Oklahoma City University |
| 2004 |
Oklahoma City University |
Chad Wensel, The Master's College |
| 2005 |
Johnson & Wales University (Florida) |
Jim Renner, Johnson & Wales University (Florida) |
| 2006 |
Oklahoma City University |
Joe Prince, Point Loma Nazarene University |
| 2007 |
Oklahoma City University |
Daniel Mitchell, Oklahoma City University |
| 2008 |
University of British Columbia |
Sam Cyr, Point Loma Nazarene University |
| 2009 |
Oklahoma Christian University |
Sam Cyr, Point Loma Nazarene University |
| 2010 |
Oklahoma City University |
Justin Lower, Malone College |
| 2011 |
Oklahoma Christian University |
Oscar Stark, Oklahoma Christian University |